Wednesday, February 12, 2014
Another question for search committees
Here's a new one that I am definitely adding to the list: What is their view of church membership?
This deserves some elaboration. Most people have some idea of what their expectations are regarding church membership—the degree of commitment, participation, responsibility, and so on that is to be expected of someone who joins the church as a member. And many people assume that everyone has roughly the same view as they do!
This is a mistake. DO NOT assume this of the church you are interviewing with.
My own view of church membership is a fairly high view; I believe strongly that commitment to, participation in, and accountability from the local church is an essential element of our spiritual health, and indeed our salvation. Like Cyprian (3rd century church father), I believe that "he cannot have God as his father who does not have the church as his mother." I think that the Bible declares—and orthodox believers through history have affirmed—that God uses his church so primarily for outreach and evangelism that, as one confession says, "there is no salvation apart from the church." I believe that a healthy and growing Christian will invariably have an active and committed presence in a local church. And I believe that, once someone has committed to a local church in membership, they should have very good and specific reasons to leave that congregation for another.
Now, I'm not under any illusion that my view of church membership is the dominant view in our 21st century western church, or even within my denomination. But I learned in one congregation how I mustn't take for granted even the assumption that most (including fellow PCA members) are "pretty close" to the same view.
I'll give you an example of how I learned this. I knew the pastor that preceded me at from seminary, and after I moved to town we had lunch a few times. In one of those times, we were talking about his ongoing sense of connection and affinity with the congregation, and I said, "I know you still think of yourself as a '[nickname for the church member].'" He looked at me with surprise and said emphatically, "I AM a [same nickname]!"
Now, this conversation took place over a year and a half after that pastor had left the congregation; during that time, he had only returned once (during my installation, and at my request). Though he had been in contact with some members, and others had followed him to another congregation, his relationship with the church I now served had no ongoing formal or regular connection. And yet, he thought of himself as a part of that body in a form no different from how any other member thought of themselves.
The analogy for how this pastor seemed to view his connection came to me later. I graduated from the University of South Carolina in 1999, and in the 15 years since I have only been back on the campus twice. I haven't attended one of my alma mater's sporting events in over 20 years, though I occasionally watch them on television (maybe two or three a year); I do check the scores on a regular basis, but at best I could be described as a tepid fan. I am still in contact—through Facebook and Twitter—with a number of my classmates, but here again it has been years since I saw most of them face-to-face. Likewise, I occasionally read with interest some news about some aspect of the school's leadership, academic development, or other recognition. And yet, in my sense of self-identification with the university I attended, I still think of myself as a "Gamecock."
That's about how this former pastor was in relation to my congregation: he was a fan—and surely a devoted and deeply-invested fan. But he was merely a fan, nevertheless. And he had succeeded in teaching many of the congregation (including most of the leadership) that church membership essentially meant being a fan.
In the end, this led to severe and sometimes devastating consequences, relationally, as my expectations AND theirs were not met. They wanted to be fans; I wanted a deeper and more lasting commitment. The bottom line: our views on church membership were very different.
Notice: this extended to much of the leadership as well. It's one thing when many lay-level members have a different understanding of what you expect from them as members; there's always room to grow, and a committed leadership can shape a culture over time that will affect consistency across the whole congregation.
In my case, the leaders and I were at odds (not all of them—and not all members in general either; but enough). What this tells me is that there was a major area of ill-fitness that I missed (and they did too) when considering whether I should be their next pastor.
I won't overlook this again—and I urge anyone else who is in candidacy to explore this topic with the congregations they are interviewing with.
Wednesday, June 30, 2010
Spiritual preparation for an interview weekend
First, remember that you will be in-residence as a minister to the people you are with during your interview weekend. They are sinners in need of God’s grace, broken and wounded, growing in their faith and knowledge of God, and being increasingly bound together as His body. Therefore, you must begin beforehand to pray for them— by name, as much as possible. You must prepare well for whatever lessons, sermons, or other preaching/teaching opportunities you will have. You should consider what you know of their circumstances and recent history, and marshall the pastoral knowledge and wisdom that you have for that context.
You also have preparation to do personally, and in terms of your candidacy. Here again, pray for your own discernment and for theirs: that your ministry among them would demonstrate accurately to everyone in what ways He could use you among them; that God would reveal to all whether there is a good “fit;” and that He would begin to bind you together if so. Ask Him to give you the endurance and fortitude to carry you through the whole interview time. Pray that they would also be both aware of and sensitive to the trials that an interview can be.
Saturday, February 20, 2010
Hacking the phone interview
- Location, location, location: make sure the place you take the call is private and quiet.
- Timing is everything: be ready when the time is right.
- The incredible "invisible" candidate:
Of course you aren’t really invisible, but it sure can feel that way. The typical phone interview deprives both parties of physical cues both facial expressions and body language. It can be very disorienting to interview with people you’ve never met or seen, especially because often there will be a pause between your answers and the next question.
There are several more good suggestions. Be sure to check out ProfHacker's piece on hacking the phone interview.
Wednesday, December 30, 2009
Academic interviews
There was a great article recently on the ProfHacker blog on "hacking" an interview for an academic position. The highlights are:
- Get your facts straight
- Keep your answers short and foster conversation
- Think about what you will be asked
- Prepare a few questions
- Wave your geek flag-- but do so cautiously
- Have fun
- ...other advice.
Tuesday, April 22, 2008
Bits and tidbits
A few articles, posts, and other such have come to my attention recently that those in transition (or considering it) may find interesting.
- How a Presbyterian Minister Should Resign. Good thoughts here on the way that a resignation is approached-- not in a strictly businesslike manner, but with care and consideration for one's responsibilities as a Pastor and Presbyter.
- PCA Ministerial Glut. Back in January, the "Warfield List" had a brief discussion (now fizzled out, alas) on how there are "too many" candidates for ministry and what to do about it. FWIW, I don't agree with most of the conclusions drawn, but my 3 or 4 readers will recognize a couple of themes that are burdens of my heart. (HT: Heidelblog)
- Finding a new job, when you're on the road. A good (brief) article from the NY Times "Shifting Careers" column. There are meta-themes here that working Pastors (and even seminary students) will be able to apply.
- The Unclutterer blog has been doing a good series on moving lately-- good advice. Catch their posts here, here, and here.
- The secret to success in ministry. A good little reflection from PastorHacks on why devotional life is important for Pastors (also has good application in seminary, BTW).
- Speed mentoring. Interesting concept-- wouldn't this be fascinating to see done at a General Assembly? (HT: 43Folders)
- The Business. Rands in Repose does it again-- this time discussing salary negotiations. As with all of his posts, this one is focused on the process in the context of the world of IT-- but there's a lot of application to be gleaned for the pastoral candidate. (I especially appreciate his advice on gauging your worth.)
Enjoy.
Wednesday, February 27, 2008
Briefly...
Here's a good (brief) piece on choosing references... eventually I'll get back to the information packet and will offer some additional thoughts to this.
I finished ordination last month, and my ordination service was 10 days ago (2/17). It was great!
I sent out a handful of proposals for the transition book yesterday. No telling how they will respond, but I'm shooting for the big guys first: Baker Academic, Eerdmans, InterVarsity Press, Zondervan. Also on this list to hit soon: Jossey-Bass, Abingdon, Alban Institute, Christian Focus, P&R, Wipf & Stock, and The Church Growth Institute.
That's all.
Saturday, July 28, 2007
Saturday, March 31, 2007
Candidacy questions, #3
- Please give a brief testimony of your Christian experience.
- Regarding your personal devotional life, briefly describe your approach and practice.
- What are your hobbies and special interests?
- Is your wife persuaded of your call to pastoral ministry?
- How do you anticipate her being involved in your ministry?
- Are you quick to admit when you are wrong and seek forgiveness? Do you quickly repent before your wife and children when you have wronged them? Is repentance a consistent part of your life?
- Would your wife and children agree with this answer?
- Give a recent example.
- In what areas do you have particular weaknesses?
- What has been the clearest evidence of God’s blessing on your ministry?
- What are your greatest strengths personally?
- Have you ever been under church discipline and if so for what?
- What goals and objectives do you have for your ministry?
- What do you envision being your primary responsibilities as an assistant pastor?
- What do you see as the greatest dangers for an assistant pastor? The greatest challenges?
- Describe briefly how you would go about carrying out your responsibilities as an assistant pastor at our church?
- Describe the type of person to whom you would be able to most effectively minister.
- Next, describe the type of person to whom you would find it most difficult to minister.
- Which PCA churches/ministers would you say have most influenced your philosophy of ministry (list at least three)?
- Briefly describe your role and style as a leader?
- What objectives do you have for your relationship to potential elders in a church?
- How do people change and what would you do to promote sincere transformation among people in your church?
- Please describe your approach to evangelism.
- What is your present involvement in evangelism?
- What is your vision concerning world missions? Have you taken any trips personally? How do you see yourself helping our church get more involved in missions?
- What is your understanding of the community in which our church is ministering?
- Briefly describe your understanding of the nature and purpose of preaching and type of sermons you normally preach?
- What does this statement mean: “Every good sermon should have both law and gospel?”
- How does the “historic-redemptive unity” of the Bible bear on preaching an OT and a NT text?
- Do you think it is possible and/or desirable to include Christ in every sermon? Explain.
- Describe your philosophy of worship.
- What style of worship do you favor? (Traditional, Liturgical, Contemporary, Blended, other) List several churches that have shaped your perspective in this regard.
- Describe how worship style reflects or forms our theology? In other words, does the way we worship effect, change or form our beliefs? If so, what does the above style (question #2) communicate?
- What are your views concerning the so-called “charismatic gifts” of the Spirit including speaking in tongues, word of knowledge and healing?
- What elements do you believe should be generally included in a worship service?
- What type of music and instrumentation do you believe are acceptable or unacceptable for a morning worship service?
- How often do you believe the sacrament of Communion should be observed and why?
- Are there any elements or activities that some include in a worship service that you believe should not be included?
- Please describe your view regarding ministry opportunities for women in the church. Specifically address what role a woman may have in the worship service and in what contexts and to whom she may teach.
Saturday, March 17, 2007
Candidacy questions, #2
- Describe your preferences for worship style; i.e., contemporary, traditional, blended, etc.
- What are the core values that define your vision for ministry?
- How do you handle conflict between people within the church?
- What are the greatest strengths in your ministry?
- What do you consider to be the primary areas for your own personal growth?
- What would you like for us to know about you that the Ministerial Data Form doesn’t tell?
- What aspects of the pastor’s job do you like most?
- The least?
- Tell us about your family.
- What are some difficult issues your family faces?
- Are your children be in public or Christian schools, or do you home-school them?
- What is your wife’s role in the church?
- Is she willing to teach a women’s Bible study or take a position on the WIC Council?
- What do you believe the role of women in the church should be?
- What kind of church are you looking for?
- Describe your relationship with the officers in your church.
- Have you thought about what goals you will have in a new calling?
- Tell us about your current financial situation.
- Do you have significant debts?
- What are your financial needs?
- What are your views on the church supporting missionaries?
- Do you visit members of the church that are shut-in or in rest homes?
- What is your ideal of ministering to young adults and singles?
- How do you feel about small groups and prayer meetings in homes?
- What are your thoughts on the church, youth, or WIC having fund raiser for special projects?
- What do you do for leadership training for church officers or would do as a senior pastor?
- What do consider profaning the Sabbath in relations to activities after church services? (examples: watching TV. playing sports, shopping or going out to eat).
- What translation do you preach out of?
- We are trying to grow a Presbytery in this area, would you be supportive and active in this process?
- Have you ever been charged with or convicted of a felony? Yes [ ] No [ ] if yes, please explain.
- Have you ever been accused of or disciplined for sexual misconduct, child or spousal abuse, or financial improprieties? Yes [ ] No [ ] If yes, from what classis? Please explain.
- What were or are the most effective programs in your church that you have been involved in?
- How do you feel about women wearing slacks or capri pants to church?
Technorati Tags: Candidacy
Monday, March 05, 2007
When does the interview end?
Rands, the Silicon Valley manager I've mentioned before, suggests that the interview really lasts for 90 days past your first day on the job. And I think he's right.
Look folks can't evaluate you accurately by just your information packet-- and neither can they really assess your value during an interview weekend. While you probably won't get fired for not handling the first ninety days (or the first six months) well, it will definitely set the tone for how your ministry will go. And since the goal is always effective ministry for the full-term of service God has called you to, starting well may be the key to finishing well (or at all).
In addition to the eight principles I've already laid out, Rands has some good ideas, including showing up early and staying late, accepting every lunch invitation you get, and saying something stupid. Rands says it well:
It's not just that you forgot to ask key questions during your initial interview process; it's that the person that you were walking into that interview isn't who you are. You're a resume, you're a referral, and you're a reputation.
Your job interview isn't over until you've asked all the questions and heard all of the stories.
Technorati Tags: Candidacy, Transition
Friday, March 02, 2007
Search committee questions
- Tell us about yourself-- who is Ed Eubanks?
- How did you come to know Christ?
- What about our position description made you excited about considering our church?
- What are your spiritual gifts?
- There are two kinds of people-- visionaries and task-oriented. Where do you place yourself?
- What does church administration mean to you?
- Tell us about your personal organizational skills-- how do you keep yourself organized?
- Define discipleship.
- Are you being discipled now?
- What makes you squirm? What questions (in discipleship) are the most difficult to answer?
- What do you struggle with?
- Are you currently discipling anyone?
- On our scale for ministry skills (1-2=acquiring; 3-5=functional; 6=others come to you as a mentor; 7=expert, could teach on it) where do you rank yourself on discipleship?
- Of those you have discipled, have they caught the vision for what discipleship is about and are they dscipling others too?
- What is your passion?
- What have you done to prepare for this interview?
- Have you ever been to this area (where the church is)?
- What do you know about the area?
- If you get the position, what is the most important thing you can do for the congregation?
- Why our church?
- What is your experience with men's ministry?
- What is your experience with small groups?
- Using our scale, how would you rank yourself on teamwork?
- How do you work with others during times of conflict? Give an example of when you have handled it well and when you haven't.
- What is your current relationship with the person who left your ministry (follow-up on #24)?
- Tell us about ___ (high-profile person I have known)?
- Why do you want to be an Assistant Pastor and not a Senior or Solo Pastor?
- Are you pursuing other opportunities?
- Detail your perfect job description.
- What does leadership training mean to you, and where do you rank yourself (on our scale)?
- Given your bent towards academia and writing, how would you marry that with your job?
- What does Marcie bring to your ministry besides just being your helpmate? What is her passion?
- What is your experience with older members in the church?
- Tell us about _____ (a person from my reference list).
- Who is the best preacher in the PCA (our denomination) right now?
Technorati Tags: Candidacy
Saturday, February 24, 2007
Dressing up for phone interviews
I know: they can't see me when we're on the phone. (And no, the interview was not a Skype video call.) But how you dress doesn't just affect the way oter people see you; it affects how you see yourself.
By dressing up for my phone interview, I felt differently than I would have if I had worn jeans or sweats and a t-shirt. I admit I wasn't as comfortable (though I have grown to be quite comfortable in dressier clothes), but I didn't want to be too comfortable. I didn't want to feel too relaxed.
Instead, I wanted to feel a level of formality in my attitude and even my physical presence that was appropriate for the situation. "Dressing up" for my interview helped that.
I don't know if this is the right call for everyone. Some guys might be so nervous for their first interview that they need every means available to make them more comfortable. But I would at least encourage you to give it a thought when you're approaching a telephone interview.
Technorati Tags: Candidacy
Tuesday, February 20, 2007
Answering Questions #3: women and ministry
While once a matter of debate similar to that of other theological controversy-- which is to say, largely theoretical and abstract for most-- the question of what role women have in the local congregation is now anything but abstract or theoretical. Indeed, one who cannot answer this question to the satisfaction of his constituents will find one portion or another quite concerned with what the future holds.
The reasoning behind this is several-fold, in my analysis:
- We cannot begin anywhere except the fact that our forefathers in the Church have mishandled this question terribly. Accusations hurled at the Church of misogyny and male chauvinism in years past were not far off the mark, at least as far as the practice of the Church goes.
- This poor practice in the past (and to a lesser degree in the present) has unfortunately been tied to the theological truths that were (mis)used to justify such action, so much that these truths have themselves become targets for skepticism. Coupled with a looser hold to the authority of the Scriptures, this is a treacherous association; however, even when the authority of Scripture is upheld, then the trustworthiness of the leadership that applies Scripture is weakened by poor practices.
- None of this is helped in any way by the fact that mature, godly men serving in strong, careful leadership roles are more scarce today than ever. While refreshing, it is often a surprising exception to find a great Elder who can lead women while esteeming their dignity. The absence of men who can handle this balance well is more the norm than the exception.
- Meanwhile, a growing number of Christian women are becoming mature to the point of surpassing their male counterparts, and they take their mature faith seriously. Thus, when called upon to lead, they do not shy away. More women than ever are, for example, pursuing training in seminaries, which prepares them well for leadership in a local congregation.
Without going much further into the underpinnings of an answer, I'll simply offer what mine is-- hoping that there is enough there for you to intuit some of the rationale. Here's how I would answer the question immediately above:
I think the first thing that must be said is that women have been dealt with poorly in the Church at large, and more particularly in the Presbyterian Church in America, and they have not been given the dignity and respect they deserve as sisters in Christ and co-laborers for the Kingdom. I believe that there is much repentance and reparation to be done in that area, and that it is only with the gracious forgiveness of the women in the church that we can even begin to move further in considering the question.
That said, I believe that there is much available to women as opportunities for service and leadership within the local congregation. Traditionally, women have been offered leadership opportunities in Children's Ministry, Youth Ministry, and Women's Ministry, and these remain wonderful opportunities for women who are called to them. However, there are many other areas of church life and ministry that the gifts and abilities that are unique to women, or at least stronger in them, are a good fit: mercy ministry, hospitality, lay leadership development, and congregational care are a few that come to mind.
Furthermore, many women have gifts and abilities that equal or surpass those of their male counterparts, and in the appropriate contexts they should be encouraged and empowered to exercise them. My understanding of the Scriptural teaching on what women can and cannot do tells me that, apart from leading and teaching in corporate worship, women are free to perform whatever tasks a non-ordained man may do. In other words, if a woman is gifted for teaching, she may teach-- provided that the context is not teaching in worship.
One final distinction on the matter: concerning the question of women as Deacons or Elders, I believe it is Scripturally forbidden, and therefore prohibited for practice today, for women to be ordained as Elders. I think that a reasonable case could be made from Scripture in favor of ordaining women to the office of Deacon, which is defined by Scripture as essentially an office of service. However, the rules of government in the PCA outlined by the Book of Church Order forbid this, and unless this were to change I believe it would be unethical-- given the vows that I am prepared to take for my own ordination-- to go against these rules. I am, however, grateful that the Book of Church Order allows for the appointment of godly men and women to assist the Diaconate in their duties.
Thursday, February 08, 2007
Answering Questions #2: "hot topics"
Honesty.
First and foremost, candidates should deal with issues honestly. By this I mean two things: be honest about what you believe, and be honest about what you know.
Do you have a position on topic X? Then state it concisely. If you believe in the practice of paedo-communion, struggle with accepting infant baptism, or consider yourself a strict reconstructionist, say so. If you think that Pastors must wear robes in the pulpit or that worship should include only Psalms in singing, be upfront about it. Don't try to hide or mask your beliefs in complex, esoteric, or misleading language, but put it in plain terms. Why would you want to imply that you don't believe what you do? If you've reached conclusions about these or other issues, you should see it as your obligation to profess those conclusions at this time.
On the other hand, if you haven't reached conclusions about an issue-- or if you simply don't know enough about it to say-- then admit this plainly, as well. It is perfectly acceptable to acknowledge that you are undecided or uninformed about them. No one can keep up with all of the issues and discussions and still be attentive to study, ministry, or family. If they happen to ask about something you know about, great-- but if you don't know, just say, "I don't know."
Charity.
The folks interviewing you are listening as much to how you answer as they are to what you answer. You may be utterly convinced that your position is true; thus, Ephesians 4 requires that you speak that truth "in love."
Said another way: when you are asked about a hot topic, the chances are that it is because the committee or even the whole church has encountered it in some way. Do you know what way that is? Are you confident that every member of the committee-- and the church-- will agree with your perspective on the matter? Would you be comfortable if the most outspoken opponent of your position were in the room? If you cannot answer these questions with a confident "yes" then you should re-think how you state your position.
The candidacy interview is not an inherent opportunity to instruct and correct the committee or team interviewing you. It is not your job (yet!) to shepherd them to a new level of understanding about difficult issues. You will demonstrate a respect for the dignity of their role as members of the search team if you deal with them charitably.
Humility.
Even if you are convinced of your position, take care to hold loosely onto it loosely enough that you don't put ideas before people. (the singular exception is, of course, if you are asked about one of those "Primary Issues"-- but of course that shouldn't fall under the category of "hot topics.")
I was recently confronted with the reality of this in my own life. A dear friend mentioned that, at times, it seems like I don't care about what other people think of me. This may be because I regard truth highly enough that I would rather be in accordance with the truth than compromise but keep the esteem of others. But my friend remarked how this sometimes made her feel rejected, as if I didn't appreciate being loved. When it comes to that, I've sinned pridefully, even though my intentions were the opposite.
Along similar lines, my friend and hero Joe Novenson commented about one of the current discussions in the PCA, sometimes known as Auburn Avenue Theology-- so called because it centers around ideas first introduced at a theological conference held at Auburn Avenue Presbyterian Church. Joe reminded me of the humility needed when he said, "Before Auburn Avenue was a theology, it was a church." That church is not essentially the ideas behind that theology, but the people of her membership.
Approaching these questions with honesty, charity, and humility, here is how I might answer a difficult question:
Q: What is your perspective on Federal Vision?
I believe that the questions raised by the proponents of a Federal Vision view are important, valuable concerns about our understanding and practice of the sacraments. In some ways, I applaud the men who have raised these questions, and I do not believe that they have always been dealt with in a loving, brotherly manner-- which has prevented fruitful, productive discussion from taking place. To be perfectly candid, I have not studied the writings of those who promote the Federal Vision view in depth, nor am I familiar with the historical writings that they appeal to with a level of confidence to comment. I have read several summaries of the issue, including some that are sympathetic, if not supportive, of Federal Vision theology, and from what I have read of these I cannot say that I fully agree with any of the main points of discussion. I am not comfortable claiming a decided position, however, nor am I convinced in any way that those who hold a Federal Vision perspective should be seen as unorthodox or unbiblical in their convictions.
Wednesday, February 07, 2007
Answering questions, pt. 1
Anticipated question #1:
"Tell us about your greatest weakness."
I've mentioned Manager Tools before, and I think they regularly offer good advice. In a recent "members only" podcast, they talked about how to handle this question in an interview. Their advice is great, and it serves everyone well-- the interviewee actually answers the question (rather than dodging it), but is also given a way to save face.
They advise an essentially three-part answer:
- Qualify your answer-- in other words, state outright that this is not your struggle in every moment. Say, "sometimes" or "in certain situations" or some other like qualification.
- State a real weakness. Don't soft-pedal or understate, and don't find something utterly irrelevant to the job.
- Tell what you are doing to improve on it. Notice the present active tense-- this is not what you plan or hope to do, but the action you are in the process of taking to strengthen what is weak.
As for me, here's something akin to the answer I'll give:
In situations where I have a conflict with someone else, I sometimes have difficulty accepting my part of the responsibility for the conflict and responding appropriately. In those moments I become defensive, rather than apologizing for my errors and seeking repentance. In the past, this has caused tension in relationships, and has hindered me in ministry. I have learned a lot about dealing with my own pride and sin through studying Ken Sande's Peacemaker, and I've recently begun reading Miroslav Volf's Free of Charge: Giving and Forgiving in a Culture Stripped of Grace which is teaching me a lot about living relationships more graciously. I have also been dialoging about this problem with my friend Dan Zink, who is Professor of Christian Counseling at Covenant Seminary.
Wednesday, January 24, 2007
What do you wear on the interview weekend?
[A disclaimer: in this post I'm assuming a lot about culture. I realize that there are many cultures in which my comments below would not apply-- even within the American context. I'm assuming, therefore, that you, the reader, understands that I'm coming from an American, protestant, mostly-white, mostly-suburban Presbyterian context, and that you'll forgive my broad-stroke claims if they don't apply to you.]
For the most part, candidacy is not a casual affair. View it like you do any job interview-- only this one lasts two and a half days. You wouldn't wear jeans, flip-flops and a worn-out Van Halen t-shirt to a job interview at a corporation, retail store, or even Starbucks; you would probably wear nice pants (not denim), dark shoes, and a nice shirt-- possibly even a tie and sport coat. Why should you view an interview at a church any differently?
A rule of thumb I always taught my Rhetoric students about public speaking is applicable here: you should plan to dress at least as nicely as the other most well-dressed person in the room. You are not a mere participant in these situations-- you are the object of everyone's attention, and the way you present yourself communicates a lot to them about how much you respect them and the situation. (Thus my thoughts from a few days ago.)
So here's a list of what I'll take when I go on my next interview weekend:
- 1-2 two-piece suits
- 1-2 sport jackets (2 if I only take 1 suit)
- 2-3 pairs of nice pants (probably 1 pair of "dress slacks" and 2 pairs of "chino" pants)
- 1 pair of black dress shoes
- 2 pair of brown shoes-- one casual and one dress
- 2 oxford dress shirts
- 2-3 other shirts (either Polo-style golf shirts or casual button-down shirts)
- 3 neckties
- Appropriate accessories (belts, socks, etc.)
Along these lines, guys: wear a sleeved, plain white undershirt. All the time. (Yes, it does look different.)
One more thing-- the suits, jackets, pants, and shirts will all go to the dry cleaner's a week before the trip. Yes, that will cost money-- probably about $20, if my experience with dry cleaners is accurate-- but I'm guaranteed to have cleaned, pressed clothes that look neat for the whole trip.
Here's a fact to take to the bank: in even the most casual American church, you will never be over-dressed in a tie and blazer. You could wear a suit to 80% of the churches in any given town and not stand out. So remember this as you're packing for your interview weekend.
Sunday, November 27, 2005
Good question
Understanding a Pastor has many responsibilities, what two areas are you most passionate about?This is one of the better questions I've seen on a pastoral search questionaire. It fairly accommodates the fact that a candidate-pastor may be passionate about a number of things, thereby avoiding all sorts of disclaiming and wordy explanation. At the same time, it gets to the point: they want to know what is the most important.
Great one.
Sunday, July 24, 2005
Digging up bones
There are legitimate reasons why someone would want to know about past troubles in a church; someone considering membership, for example, may wish to know about the church they will join. And I not only admit legitimacy but encourage asking about such things in the context of candidacy and placement. A candidate-pastor must know about the church he will serve.
But how much is too much to ask? How far back must a candidate go to get the information he needs? Five years? 10? 20?
If the situation was turned around, my guess is that the answer would be quite conservative. What if someone considering membership (or, better said, being considered for membership) had to recount their own past history in order to pass muster? “Let's hear it-- all the juicy details,” I can hear them saying. Frankly, this is the more appropriate consideration-- not, “Is this church good enough for me to join?” but, “Am I good enough for membership in this church?”
[I realize that the last idea goes against the grain of our individualist culture: in the “me-first” world we Americans live in, how dare I suggest that the whole is greater than the sum of its parts?]
“But wait,” you say. “Isn't there room for growth in this sort of circumstance? What about grace?” Indeed, grace is hard at work in my life-- and (hopefully!) in the lives of believers coming before a church for membership. In fact, it is that very grace-- NOT the circumstances of their history-- that should be the basis for membership.
This came to mind recently as I learned that a church that I once worked with was soon to be without a pastor. I pondered whether I would want to serve that church as their pastor, and upon deciding that I would want to, it occurred to me that they might not give me fair consideration. Why? Because they knew me 10 years ago. They saw me fail repeatedly. They are aware of the sin and simple immaturity of my past. Would they allow for the maturity and growth God has brought about in my life?
How much allowance should we who are candidates give churches? If we-- as the individual members of a congregation-- would hope and even expect the rest of the congregation to give us grace for our past mistakes and foibles, shouldn't we (as candidate-pastors, potential members, or outsiders looking in) also give congregations grace for their past as a collective group, in hope and expectation that God has been at work to sanctify His church?
I don't know how far back to go, but I do know this: it's what lies ahead that is more important. If past problems are still causing a stir, then my concern shouldn't be with the history but with the present. On the other hand, if there is evidence that healing and reconciliation has occurred, that is cause for praise and thanksgiving.
Every church has a past that is filled with sin. Why dwell on past sins unnecessarily, if God has reconciled those sins?
Thursday, July 14, 2005
Selling dreams
I recently re-read a great book, Selling the Dream by Guy Kawasaki. Kawasaki presents evangelism in exactly this way. He suggests that the best marketing of ideas, whether it be for products or causes, is done through evangelism. This is because anyone can advertise an idea, but no one evangelizes something they don't truly believe in. Thus, Guy defines evangelism as it applies to “marketing” (to use the term in its broadest sense) as “selling the dream”-- thus, the title of his book.
Now if you think that Kawasaki is equating products or business ideas with the Gospel, you've misunderstood. Guy, a Christian who is a member of Menlo Park Presbyterian Church in California, uses the idea of evangelism very loosely compared with its biblical sense. But I think he is onto something about marketing and persuasion that is very applicable to placement.
If you're with me on the importance of a candidate's sense of calling, you'll follow me on evangelism as well. Do you believe you are called to ministry? Is it a part of your identity-- even similar to your calling as a Christian? Then you should feel compelled to convince others of this calling to ministry, as well. And convincing them out of your own genuine belief, rather than out of a sense of obligation (as advertising might be understood), is all that is meant by evangelism.
Put another way, when you dream of what God will have you doing, what does that look like? Now what if you could do exactly that if you could only sell others on the same dream? See the connection? Selling the dream is exactly what we do when we candidate well. It isn't false advertising or misrepresentation; it is putting ourselves forth as everything we believe ourselves to be. That's good candidacy.
Saturday, June 11, 2005
“Selling yourself”
One of the best things I learned from retail sales was how to simultaneously make a sale and satisfy a customer. It works like this: figure out what the customer really wants and needs, then sell them that. Pretty simple, right? Not so fast...
First of all, the customer often does not know what they want or need. They usually think they do; it requires a greater-than-average level of humility to admit that they don't understand their own needs or desires. Nevertheless, most of the time they don't have any clear idea of what they are shopping for. They have some ideas-- for example, a customer at a camera store knows what kind of pictures they usually take now, or would if they had a camera. But when it comes to camera models, features and functions, or technical specifications and capabilities, they rarely even have a clue, let alone the language to articulate it.
This presents a second obstacle: since they don't really know which products meet their needs and which do not, it is often possible to sell them whatever you want them to buy. In fact, I had co-workers who employed this tactic: they pushed whatever products offered them the best commissions, whether or not that was what their customers were looking for.
It is because customers don't know what they need or want, however, that they have come to a retail store in first place. They need someone who can ask the right questions, who knows the available product lines, and who can take answers and products together for the right recommendation. That's why they would come to me. When I worked at a camera store, for instance, I knew the specs and abilities of every camera, lens, and flash unit we sold. I also knew the right questions to ask to determine which products would best fit a customer, and could make recommendations based on what they want and need, even if they couldn't specify this themselves.
It works the same way in pastoral placement. Churches often don't know how to articulate what they are looking for in a pastor, but they will know if they get it or not.
In response to a previous post about a candidate's sense of calling, a comment was made about the integrity of “selling yourself.” I may misunderstand what that commenter intended, but “selling myself” in pastoral candidacy reminds me of my co-workers who would push products for the sake of the commission: both are only after the short-term, dollar-bringing solution.
My co-workers may have earned a fast buck through a commission on, say, a camera body and lens. But if that camera did not meet the needs or desires of the customer, you can bet that customer would not return to buy another camera from them; in fact, they may not return to our store at all (after all, they believed they were getting what they needed, but were deceived). In the long run, determining what met their needs and selling them that product would produce a trusting relationship that would result, in time, in far greater amounts of sales and commissions. Pushing the wrong product may satisfy for now, but it will leave a salesman wanting in the future.
Likewise, a candidate who “sells himself” to a Search Committee-- he tells them what he thinks they want to hear so that they will offer him the position-- will mirror my commission-minded co-workers. It may produce a short-term satisfaction on both sides: the candidate-church thinks it is getting what it desires, and the candidate-pastor gets a placement (and therefore a paycheck). Long-term, however, both will be found wanting. The pastor will likely be unfulfilled in his work, since he had to misrepresent his own sense of calling to get the position. The church will realize quickly that they were taken by a fast-talker, and become even more difficult to shepherd. Everyone loses.
On the other hand, if a candidate-pastor follows my lesson from retail-- figure out what the church really wants and needs, then offer them that (if he can)-- then everyone wins. To do this, a candidate-pastor has to figure out what questions will reveal whether a church is looking for someone like him. Ask the right questions, and he will know if he is the man for the job. If not, then his integrity should lead him to say so. If he is the one, it is far from a “sales job” or “selling himself” to help them understand that it is a good fit.
This comes back to the basic assumption that you know what you're called to do. You must be the expert on you-- in retail terms, you have to know what kind of “product” you are, and what needs and desires you can and cannot satisfy. If you know this and learn to articulate it, what you present is no sales pitch-- it's the truth.